Questioner: A brother and a sister have agreed to marry each other, but it later became clear to the sister that the brother is not upon an authentic ‘aqeedah. Can she annul the agreement?
Dr Sharof: All praise is for Allaah alone. They wish to marry each other and they have agreed to marry, but it later became clear that the brother’s ‘aqeedah is not authentic, for example, he is an Ahmadee. Should they still carry on?
Why will you marry a disbeliever? You must not marry him. A Muslim must not marry a disbeliever. Such thing happened in a village and in this case they have married (each other). The brother pretended as if he was a Muslim upon the Sunnah. He had married the sister before it became clear that he was an Ahmadee. In fact, he is one of the people propagating Ahmadiyyah in that village. So the people who were upon Sunnah were asking how to resolve the issue because she had already bore him two children. We responded that the marriage is null and void from the day it became clear that he was an Ahmadee because Allaah does not permit a believing woman to marry a disbelieving man. This is because the Ahmadees are disbelievers. They believe that there is another Prophet after Prophet Muhammad (sollaLloohu ‘alayhi wa sallam), and whosoever believes this (assertion) is a disbeliever. There is no more marriage between them. This is regarding the people who had married let alone a person who is yet to get married. When we were asked about what they could do, we advised that one of them should marry her as a second or third wife, (but) they were reluctant about it. So I interrogated them as to how they will aid the Muslims if they cannot take the pain to do something like this. Na’am. That is it.
[Source: Q&A session of the tape, “The virtues of Aaishah”]
Transcribed by Aboo Aaishah Al Odeomeey